Amish Peanut Butter Custard Pie

[Judy]

\r\nOn a trip through Indiana, my husband and I stopped at a restuarant for lunch and all they had for dessert was one slice of this pie. I told the waitress it didnt\' sound too good so I would pass on the pie. She told me she would not charge me if I didn\'t like it, so I tried a bite and it was so delicious, I asked for the recipe! I make this pie for family gatherings, and it has actually become a tradition by now - my 3 sons love this pie and make it themselves now that they have their own places. It is important to use the exact ingredients and do not substitute anything. Organic will turn out best. Compliments guaranteed.

[CarolsCritterCare]

This sounds real good!

[Computerspacedog]

I really wanted to give this recipe to my friend. She Had been searching for a peanut butter custard type pie. Anyway, It looks as though you have left out some ingredients, and some steps in the directions. Can you fix it? Thanks.

[MrKhay]

I see directions to add vanilla pudding, but I don't see vanilla pudding in the ingredients list. whadup wit dat?