|
In this case, yes. Generally, I think it depends on the circumstances. This was premeditated. She is old enough to know it was wrong and did it anyway because she thought there would be no consequences to her, and that it was ok that her mother might get into a lot of trouble over it.
Now, an accidental death in a spur-of-the-moment blowup between students, no, probably not. But this wasn't an accident, nor was it in-the-heat-of-the-moment.
Frankly, our extended notion of childhood as lasting into the twenties is a very recent development and while I'm all for giving kids the time to learn before throwing them to the wolves of job and rent and insurance, and protecting them from predatory adults (both sexual predators and businesses looking for cheap expendable labor), they reach an age of responsibility far earlier than we give them credit for. Kids like this don't grow up to be responsible adults. They grow up thinking there are no consequences for their behavior because we dismiss it as "youth". Anyone who would commit premeditated murder, intending the outcome to be death or life-long crippling in their victim, and understanding what that means, needs to be removed from society for the good of society. Permanently.
I recognize that our system is in many ways broken. We've gone from a court system that would rather let ten guilty people go free than incarcerate one innocent person, to a system that would rather jail ten innocent people for the sake of catching that one guilty person, just so people's thirst for revenge and blame can be slaked, no matter who it destroys in the process. And I think that needs to change. But it doesn't change that fact that people like that girl still need to be dealt with in a way that keeps her from hurting anyone else.
__________________
I have a unique relationship with Lady Luck. She smiles on me often. Usually it's with derision.
|
